Little Earthquakes all the way. but I like everything up to Boys for Pele. she sorta lost me after that. I don't know if I just haven't given those a chance. I did like her Slayer cover though... come to think of it, I like all of her covers.
Little Earthquakes came out during a pretty difficult time in my life and it really hit home, so it's forever gonna sit next Disintegration by the Cure, the Queen is Dead by the Smiths and Nevermind by Nirvana as one of those albums that hits home everytime I hear it.